Process biology and start-upExplainer

How the bicarbonate buffer works in a biogas plant and what alkalinity gives

The bicarbonate buffer protects the digester pH against the effects of fatty acids. We explain the chemistry of the CO₂–HCO₃⁻ system, the role of ammonia and the point of measuring alkalinity.

Published 6 min readFeedstockData Editorial Team

Other language versions: Polski, Deutsch, Español, Français, Italiano, Nederlands.

Niebieski statyw z probówkami typu Eppendorf i pojemnik z końcówkami do pipet.
Photo Gannu03 / Wikimedia Commons, licence CC BY-SA 4.0, source file; changes: cropping

The bicarbonate buffer is a chemical system that keeps the digester pH within a narrow range even though acids are constantly formed in the process. It consists of dissolved CO₂ (which forms carbonic acid in water) and bicarbonate ions HCO₃⁻. When acids increase, bicarbonates neutralise them. As long as the buffer reserve suffices, the pH hardly changes, and when the reserve is exhausted, the pH falls quickly.

The chemistry in a few sentences

CO₂ dissolved in the fermentation liquid forms an equilibrium: CO₂ + H₂O ⇌ H₂CO₃ ⇌ H⁺ + HCO₃⁻. The first dissociation constant of carbonic acid corresponds to a pKa of about 6.3–6.4 (at a temperature close to room temperature; at digester temperature it is slightly different). The buffer works best near the pKa, that is within about one pH unit around this value. The typical pH in an agricultural digester is 7–8, so the system operates in the upper part of its range, where HCO₃⁻ ions dominate and the buffer capacity against acids is considerable, particularly thanks to the high bicarbonate concentration.

Biogas usually contains several dozen per cent CO₂, so the partial pressure of this gas above the liquid is high and the liquid is "saturated" with it. That is why the bicarbonate buffer is built into the process itself: CO₂ is constantly formed in it, and HCO₃⁻ ions are the result of dissociation. A change in biogas composition, for example a fall in the CO₂ share after intensive degassing, affects the equilibrium and the pH.

Alkalinity is not pH

Alkalinity measures the ability of a liquid to accept H⁺ ions when titrated with acid. It is most often expressed in mg or g CaCO₃/l. The measurement is the basis of the FOS/TAC indicator (the ratio of volatile organic acids to carbonate alkalinity), described in the article on measuring and interpreting FOS/TAC.

In practice:

  • pH answers the question "what is the state now".
  • Alkalinity answers the question "how much more acid will we take before the pH starts to fall".
  • A high, stable pH with rising volatile fatty acids (VFA) means the buffer is being used up and the symptoms will appear later.

Alkalinity ranges differ depending on the substrate, temperature and technology. In agricultural installations they are usually values in the order of a few to a dozen or so g CaCO₃/l, but every installation must be assessed on the basis of its own multi-year measurement series. The reference point is the trend, not a one-off number.

Where alkalinity in the digester comes from

  1. Dissolved CO₂ and bicarbonates, formed in the fermentation process.
  2. Ammonia and ammonium ions NH₄⁺ from the breakdown of proteins and urea. The ammonium ion is in itself a weak acid, but the accompanying bicarbonate anions increase the alkalinity of the liquid. For this reason substrates rich in protein (slurry, slaughterhouse waste, poultry processing residues) raise alkalinity.
  3. Salts of organic acids and other alkaline compounds brought in with the substrate.

A high level of ammonium nitrogen raises alkalinity, but at the cost of a risk of inhibition of methanogens, especially acetoclastic ones. High alkalinity from slurry is therefore no reason to be carefree. You can read more about inhibition thresholds in the article on ammonia in the digester.

What uses up the buffer

The buffer is used up by acids: VFA formed in acidogenesis, lactic acid from acidified silages, acids from organic overloading, a sudden change in feed composition. When methanogens cannot keep up with the consumption of acids (e.g. after poisoning, a fall in temperature or too rapid an increase in the dose), VFA accumulate, the buffer is used up, the pH eventually falls, and this inhibits methanogenesis and deepens the problem. The mechanism of acidification is described in the article on digester acidification.

A good warning signal is a fall in alkalinity at constant substrate doses or a rising FOS/TAC indicator. It is worth recording changes together with pH, temperature, biogas composition and doses.

Alkaline additives: when and with what caution

Sodium bicarbonate, carbonate, lime or other compounds that supply alkalinity are used in the literature and in practice. They are auxiliary agents. Their use only temporarily raises the buffer, while the cause (overloading, inhibition, a cold feed) remains. Limitations remain to be discussed:

  • An excess of sodium ions can inhibit microorganisms; calcium can promote the precipitation of carbonate deposits.
  • A sharp rise in pH increases the share of free ammonia, which at a high concentration of ammonium nitrogen is a risk in itself.
  • Dosing chemicals requires an approved site instruction and a risk assessment, and the quantities are chosen on the basis of analyses, not universal rules.

The first-choice response is therefore usually a reduction in the dose, better mixing, supplementing missing trace elements or changing the structure of the feed. An alkaline additive makes sense as an element of a start-up or recovery plan, not as a standing practice.

An example of thinking about dynamics

Imagine a digester in which the dose of a starch-rich substrate rises over several days. Acidogens produce acids faster than methanogens consume them. VFA rise, and the bicarbonate buffer neutralises successive portions of acid, so the pH hardly changes for a long time. During this time alkalinity declines steadily, and the FOS/TAC indicator rises. Only when the buffer reserve is nearly exhausted does the pH begin to fall, and then intervention is much harder, because the methanogens are already being inhibited. An operator who looks only at pH learns of the problem with a delay of the order of days. An operator who tracks alkalinity and VFA sees the trend earlier and can reduce the dose before acidification occurs.

Why taking a sample affects the result

The fermentation liquid is saturated with CO₂ under hydrostatic pressure and at process temperature. After a sample is taken, gas begins to escape and the pH rises, which falsifies the reading relative to conditions in the tank. The pH measurement is therefore made immediately, and samples for alkalinity analysis are cooled and analysed within a set time, by the same procedure every time. A reliable trend comes from the repeatability of the method, not from the accuracy of a single measurement.

Tips for the operator

  • Measure alkalinity and VFA regularly (not only pH) and record the trend.
  • React to the direction of change, not to a single reading.
  • Remember that the sample must be taken representatively and analysed within a set time, because CO₂ escapes from the sample and changes the pH.
  • When changing to a substrate richer in protein, remember the trade-off: higher alkalinity and a higher ammonia level.

Understanding the bicarbonate buffer puts the whole of biological diagnostics in order: pH, FOS/TAC, VFA and ammonia are four perspectives on the same system. More on the relationship between pH and the buffer is in the article pH in the digester: range, measurement, buffer.

Sources

  1. IEA Bioenergy Task 37: Energy from Biogas
  2. Fachagentur Nachwachsende Rohstoffe (FNR): publikacje o biogazie
  3. European Biogas Association

Questions and answers

Is it enough to measure pH to control the buffer?

No. pH responds with a delay, because alkalinity cushions the inflow of acids. Measuring alkalinity and the concentration of volatile fatty acids gives an earlier warning.

This question in the FAQ